Scores and Comments

20.c.pr.800.245

Hannah Baumgarten

Application Details

Proposal TypeSpecific Cultural Project - Individual Artist
Request Amount
$24,950
Total Score552.000
Average Score92.000

Panelist Scores

Panelist Excellence Impact Management Accessibility Total
Barry Angie 35 27 19 10 91
Frost James 36 27 19 9 91
Garcia Flora Maria 36 27 19 8 90
Mitchell Deborah 39 28 20 9 96
Person Jenni 37 25 20 10 92
Servon Jody 38 28 18 8 92

Comments

Barry Angie - Score: 91.000

Excellence: clear goals, objectives and activities. I wish the activities were fleshed out more - this would help me understand the specifics necessary to complete the projects. Handing out cards at the performances will be key-  I feel like most of your audience will not understand the concepts you are trying to express and actually be put off by this “invasion” into their daily life. If they have something to read to help them understand that will greatly increase your positive impact. 

I wish there were more partners - have you reached out to local colleges or high schools, or are the performers all coming from your dance company? This seems like a missed opportunity.

Impact: It is a low impact numbers wise, but I realize you’ll reach more once this hits social media. Again, I feel like this is an opportunity to reach out to colleges to involve students in this project. Since so much of the marketing of the project has to be on social media, younger participants are a natural fit. The educational and outreach components are not being fully realized.

Management: inkind- who is the marketing that is donating part of it? And I thought rehearsal space was covered? Why is there a line for rehearsal space? I’m glad to see you have other sources of income, like the Knight Arts Challenge- is this secured? And who is the individual support? I wish there was more information regarding these income sources in the explanation. 

Have you talked to the sites yet? The management of the water taxis or the hotel? Is this even allowed? I’m glad you’re checking first and securing permits.

Thank you for including pictures of the sites- this makes it much easier to visualize. 


Frost James - Score: 91.000
Love to see importatn work continuing. Low number impact, but artistically it is strong.... shown in support by Knight Foundation. How accessible is Water Taxi?
Garcia Flora Maria - Score: 90.000
{No comments provided.}
Mitchell Deborah - Score: 96.000
{No comments provided.}
Person Jenni - Score: 92.000

Why not collabs related to the issues addressed to really activate the conversation about these important issues? Maybe just not outlined here?

For example, maybe an HIV service organization would sponsor some expenses or plan a discussion around a performance, or bring more PR......... 

 

Thank you for addressing company vs personal practice.

Servon Jody - Score: 92.000
Excellent work that will engage the public in exciting ways. Well conceived project and application.