Scores and Comments

19.c.ps.102.138

The St. Augustine Community Chorus, Incorporated

Application Details

Proposal TypeGeneral Program Support - Discipline-Based
Request Amount
$17,069
Total Score483.000
Average Score80.500

Panelist Scores

Panelist Excellence Impact Management Accessibility Total
Ackley Malecha Jan 31 24 15 10 80
Allocco Kelly 38 27 14 6 85
Calzolari Laura 35 27 13 7 82
Miller Lisa 33 23 14 10 80
Shannon Jerome 35 20 10 10 75
Stringer Amanda 32 27 15 7 81

Comments

Ackley Malecha Jan - Score: 80.000

Incomplete information: no partmernsip or timeline information (some could be surmised from the support materials)

Goals and measurable objectives are not clear

Grant funds are requested for soloists and professional fees, but it is unclear what repertoire or type of performance this would be used for; the narrative states that the director chooses soloists from the choir

Allocco Kelly - Score: 85.000

Current & Next Fiscal Year Operating Budgets should be balanced.  They are showing huge surpluses also with no explanation.

Accessibility narrative is only focused on the physical environment.

These comments were also included in last year's evaluation, but I do not see any changes were made to these areas.

 

Calzolari Laura - Score: 82.000

Collaboration with and financial support of the youth chorus is strong - building lifelong appreciation of and participation in music, intergeneration interaction, etc.

 

Management: It is not possible to assess excellence without full programs and particularly audio and/or video clips.  (although you mention these are posted on youtube. Please consider inclusion in your next application.

Miller Lisa - Score: 80.000
Good description of the proposal and impact you make. I don't see any partnerships or timelines. Is there an explanation for the increase in budgets from last year to the current year to the next year?
Shannon Jerome - Score: 75.000
no partnerships. no timeline. no work samples (video/audio).
Stringer Amanda - Score: 81.000
{No comments provided.}