Scores and Comments

19.c.ps.141.309

The Players, Inc.

Application Details

Proposal TypeGeneral Program Support - Discipline-Based
Request Amount
$138,000
Total Score576.000
Average Score96.000

Panelist Scores

Panelist Excellence Impact Management Accessibility Total
Carr Kevin 40 30 15 10 95
Conner Tracey 39 30 18 10 97
Dale Mary-Margaret 37 29 19 10 95
Flynt-Garrett Debra 37 30 20 10 97
Hopkins Rebecca 37 29 19 10 95
Lynch Lindsay 39 30 18 10 97

Comments

Carr Kevin - Score: 95.000

commendable scholarship program

extensive goals and objectives and programming

100 percent increase in space rental/mortgage. Plans to address?

strong evaluation plan

very ambitious planned revenue increases (contracted services)... explain. Is that feasible?

Why the huge fluctuation in corporate support? I have concerns about sustainability/consistency of your revenue streams.

Conner Tracey - Score: 97.000
Excellence - Extensive programs and outreach.
Dale Mary-Margaret - Score: 95.000

Proposal description is blank.

Well-prepared proposal with a good commitment to the community and providing a wide-range of options.

Appreciate commitment to providing titles that present topical issues. Would also appreciate more diversity of voices and gender parity in titles.

 

Flynt-Garrett Debra - Score: 97.000

Mission Statement is supported by the clearly defined goals, measurable objectives, and extensive activities.

I am confident in the ability of the organization to carry out the proposal.

The organization provides vital cultural services to the community.

Specific economic impact information was provided

Educational and outreach components fully serve the constituency and are appropriate.

Very appropriate and effective marketing/promotion/publicity and audience development/expansion efforts.

I am very confident in the organization's fiscal stability and ability to carry out the proposed activities given the operating budget, grant proposal budget, and fiscal information.

I am very confident in the ability of the applicant to sustain the programs after the grant period.

 

Hopkins Rebecca - Score: 95.000

Clear goals, objectives, and activities

solid impact

Solid marketing

Support material did not include any outside voices. Media or Letters of support.

Lynch Lindsay - Score: 97.000

Excellence: Slightly confusing timeline

Impact: Good economic impact data.

Management: There are possible financial stability issues. Strong evaluation plan. Why is such a decline in private support predicted?