Scores and Comments

19.c.pr.180.175

Springfield Preservation and Revitalization Council, Inc.

Application Details

Proposal TypeSpecific Cultural Project - Discipline-Based
Request Amount
$25,000
Total Score464.000
Average Score92.800

Panelist Scores

Panelist Excellence Impact Management Accessibility Total
Cox Elaine 38 28 19 10 95
Jose Brian 37 28 19 9 93
Palkhivala Tania 36 26 20 8 90
Rivera Darren 37 24 19 10 90
Rusconi Ellen 39 28 19 10 96

Comments

Cox Elaine - Score: 95.000

Diverse partnerships show that you program with a neighborhood-first mentality. Love that you include spoken word and yoga. Very diverse and thoughtful in your neighborhood programming. 

Has any of your programming been altered or added per surveys and feedback? Would be interested in seeing survey responses.  

Love your marketing. 

Jose Brian - Score: 93.000

On a personal note: I love the idea of PorchFest!

As a reviewer, I would like to see the organization's mission statement tightened up.

Goals and objectives are measurable. there is evidence for strong and extant partnerships.

Impact is demonstrable, but attendance numbers do not add up to 12,000.

Budget looks strong and attainable. I would like to see the way evaluation will be measured and out into practice. What are the metrics?

Impressive number of volunteer hours.

Due to the nature of the activities, there is some limitation to providing access to all. Otherwise, there is good evidence of wide-spectrum accessibility.

Palkhivala Tania - Score: 90.000
{No comments provided.}
Rivera Darren - Score: 90.000

PorchFest seems like a great event. It would have been nice to see more detail about the event's economic impact, given the organization's mission statement cites strengthening the economy as a goal.

Rusconi Ellen - Score: 96.000

Goals, Objectives and Activities very clearly presented.

Partnerships are specific.

Timeline would benefit from including more aspetcs of producing

Impact is high with good expansion

Impact narrative covers a lot of relevant areas.  More quantified data would strengthen this already strong section

Marketing and Promotion - specify size of email list, social media, etc. to give context

Fiscal condition shows good financial management and prcatices

Evaluation - I like the inclusion of community meetings and volunteer assessment

Budget is very complete

Project budget is very resonable

Good accessibility

Very strong materials and great video