Scores and Comments

19.c.pr.200.048

City of Chipley

Application Details

Proposal TypeSpecific Cultural Project - Arts In Education
Request Amount
$24,750
Total Score447.000
Average Score89.400

Panelist Scores

Panelist Excellence Impact Management Accessibility Total
Cox Elaine 33 26 19 10 88
Jose Brian 33 24 20 10 87
Palkhivala Tania 37 28 20 10 95
Rivera Darren 36 24 20 9 89
Rusconi Ellen 35 26 18 9 88

Comments

Cox Elaine - Score: 88.000

I think the weakest part of this grant is the education study guide. I would take a look at how I could make that stronger, to create a tool that teachers can actually use in the classroom. What ages are your shows marketed to? I think multiple resource guides for each show would be more appropriate- then they can be tailored to each grade/education standard/ skill level.

Would be great for you to include satisfaction and impact surveys. For example how many students became engaged in aviation and STEAM after seeing FLIGHT?

Jose Brian - Score: 87.000

Applicant provides ample evidence of programs supporting mission. Reviewer would like to see goals and measurable objectives described. Reviewer would like more details of partnerships.

Applicant provides strong support of educational impact, but no mention of economic impact.

To the degree possible, applicant gives support in management section and accessibility section.

Palkhivala Tania - Score: 95.000

Under partnerships, it would be useful to sight specific past partners even if they are not slated for collaboration during the proposal period.

The application instructions request fully measurable objectives in the Proposal Description section. I do not see any language about the metrics used to measure success of this Specific Cultural Project.

Do you annually perform in all counties statewide? If not, please only identify which counties you perform in most each year to give reviewers an idea of how many counties you will perform in during a grant period.

Rivera Darren - Score: 89.000

Impact score would have been higher if efforts to target under-served populations were described. The application states "population groups served will also be dependent on locations where performances will take place." After at least three years of grant funding, it would be nice to have seen historical data about populations served or a plan for targeting specific groups.

Rusconi Ellen - Score: 88.000

Variety of shows and programs offered

timeline could include producing aspects (booking timing, etc.)

Clear narrative.  Very flexible

study guide is very good