---

Scores and Comments

19.c.ps.170.685

Museum of Contemporary Art Jacksonville, Inc.

Application Details
Proposal Type	General Program Support - Discipline-Based
Request Amount	$150,000
Total Score	631.000
Average Score	90.143

Panelist Scores

Panelist	Excellence	Impact	Management	Accessibility	Total
Esler Jennifer	40	27	18	8	93
Gelman Elizabeth	36	27	20	10	93
Hughes Michael	35	26	18	9	88
Joseph Samuel	36	27	18	10	91
Norton Heather	33	26	17	9	85
Overton Robert	38	28	18	10	94
Wolfe Bell Erin	36	27	16	8	87

Comments
Esler Jennifer - Score: 93.000
Excellence section is beautifully done. Impact section describes highly significant, but not compelling information about economic impact. Had to mark down on accessibility due to length of answer and years since 504 review.
Gelman Elizabeth - Score: 93.000
{No comments provided.}
Hughes Michael - Score: 88.000
program offerings are noteworthy.
Joseph Samuel - Score: 91.000
The reviewer needed more detailed information on the fiscal condition and sustainability of the organization. The reviewer needed more budget details to address some issues in the submitted budget (i.e. big budget fluctuations in expenses and income) It is important that applicants submit letters of support from their stakeholders, partners, and/or constituents to show outside commitment for their work.
Norton Heather - Score: 85.000
Clear mission and goals and objectives were mostly measurable with clear targets defined but some did not provide as much detail (for example - increased contact hours for MOCA Jacksonville's core educational programs - what percentage or what is meaningful growth?). Partnerships could have been defined beyond three programs, unless those are all that exist. For Impact - marketing plan was not layed out with clear approach aside from social media/website plan, some program numbers were not included even though those programs were listed as key elements to the plan like the MOCA camps. Listed a 3 million ROI to the economy but did not describe how this figure was calculated or where it was drawn from.
Overton Robert - Score: 94.000
{No comments provided.}
Wolfe Bell Erin - Score: 87.000
{No comments provided.}